For one night only, in November of 1993, an eight-man tournament featured two men fighting with no rules (except for eye gouges and mouth hooks) inside an eight-sided cage. Winner for each match will take on each other, until we determined who the baddest man on the planet at the end of the night. At that time, the event called the Ultimate Fighting Championship (UFC) was the closest that you can get to a legal street fight on TV.
No rules, which means it's the closest thing to a street fight. You would expect some burly, muscular freak with natural fighting skills and street certified tough guy to beat the hell out everyone in the tournament, right? If you haven't seen that night in Denver, you'd be surprised to what had transpired.
Royce Gracie, a skinny 169 pound Brazilian wearing some white pajama, defeated three opponents with an average of 50 pounds of advantage against him, in under 5 minutes total, on his way to win the first ever UFC tournament. That's right! Imagine three 220 pound fighters choked out by someone relatively half their size, for a total of only 299 seconds.
What's more incredible is that Gracie won three out of the first four tournaments in the UFC. His brother Rorion Gracie brought the concept of Brazilian Vale Tudo (literally meaning "anything goes" in Portuguese) in the United States, to determine which martial art is most effective on any fighting conditions. It's no secret that Rorion wanted to demonstrate the effectiveness of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu in real fighting by bringing in Royce to represent the discipline for the event.
So what's the deal about the Gracie brothers trying to show what Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu (BJJ) is all about? For one, the family patriarch Helio Gracie is the founder of BJJ (or sometimes known as Gracie Jiu-Jitsu). Until his death, Helio Gracie was the only living 10th degree Black Belt of that discipline. If Royce was only a 6th degree Black Belt, just imagine how badass his father was. Back in Brazil, Helio in his prime used to hold "the Gracie Challenge", where they allegedly sent open invitations to anybody to beat any member of the Gracie family, with challenge bets as much as $100,000, to prove how effective BJJ is.
Because of Royce's brilliance inside the Octagon during the early years of what is now called Mixed Martial Arts (MMA), fighters have incorporated BJJ to complement their other skills. Today, it would be hard to find a mixed martial artist who doesn't train Jiu-Jitsu.
However, in recent times, there are a few fighters who have been skeptical about the discipline, saying how black belts in Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu aren't a threat today, as compared to the early days of MMA. Some would even go as far as saying, if you punch a BJJ black belt in the face, all his credentials are knocked off with it.
It's not difficult to back up the argument, since fighters with a wrestling base has dominated the MMA scene lately. Wrestlers and strikers have found a way to control the fight against fighters with high Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu credentials. Some observers think that, without the use of a gi and wearing MMA gloves may hinder their grappling performance, especially with chokes and leg locks, and therefore may not be as effective today as it was back then.
So the question is, does Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu still work in the modern MMA scene?
If you're one of the skeptics of BJJ, let me answer you back with another question: do you think you can attain success as a mixed martial artist without even trying to learn Jiu-Jitsu at all? Brock Lesnar's first fight with Frank Mir was a clear demonstration on how wrestlers with a lack of knowledge or experience in BJJ won't get you anywhere. Though he dominated majority of the fight, Lesnar made a critical mistake of putting his leg where Mir can attack, and was submitted in 90 seconds.
Remember when Chuck Liddell was known to be a wrestler, but found success as a striker during his reign as the UFC Light Heavyweight champion? Casual fans (aka TUF noobs) had no idea that Chuck was a successful wrestler before transitioning to MMA.
What's Liddell's relevance in this debate? Liddell used his wrestling in reverse, to avoid being taken down and keep the fight standing up. The same goes for Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu practitioners. While success among fighters with a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu base is considerably lower nowadays, that's because all fighters have adapted BJJ into their training to avoid getting submitted. Like in Lesnar's case, without submission defense, you will get choked out or get your limbs broken.
In other words, modern fighters have used BJJ in reverse, to avoid or even escape any submission attempt. In fact, fighters can be successful with no wrestling experience but with BJJ training as opposed to those with no BJJ training but are tremendous wrestlers.
It's just that the sport of MMA has evolved tremendously, that if you only brought BJJ to the table, you will get owned on the feet. Same thing with fighters who don't have a Jiu-Jitsu experience will also get owned, this time on the ground. That's how the Gracies have struggled lately, due to their lack of skill in other elements of MMA, which makes BJJ look bad. But it shouldn't, since Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu is still an integral part in fighting.
So I conclude that BJJ still works well. It may not be as evident or as a primary offensive weapon, but you cannot survive an MMA match without any knowledge of Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu. Just ask Chael Sonnen, who was 90 seconds away to winning the UFC Middleweight belt after dominating the entire match with his wrestling, only to be submitted from the bottom via triangle choke by defending champion Anderson Silva, thanks to Nogueira brothers' Jiu-Jitsu.
If you still disagree, go ahead and fight a Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu black belt.